Old Fashioned Mixes Review — Is It Worth It? [2026]
.jpg)
Old Fashioned Mixes
Aged & Charred's all-natural Old Fashioned cocktail syrup, made in the USA with no preservatives or artificial flavors — available in Signature, Cherry Pecan Pie and Maple After Dark.
Are the Old Fashioned Mixes worth buying?
Yes — if you want a genuinely all-natural cocktail syrup rather than the artificial mixers common at the liquor store. Each bottle is made in the USA with real ingredients (dark sweet cherry juice concentrate, natural orange, gentian root, cinnamon, clove and cardamom extracts) and no preservatives, artificial flavors, colors or sweeteners, yielding 32 drinks per bottle at a quarter-ounce pour. It's the most affordable entry point into Aged & Charred's cocktail lineup and pairs naturally with the brand's smoker kits.
An all-natural syrup built for Old Fashioneds
Old Fashioned Mixes is Aged & Charred's standalone cocktail syrup line, sold separately from the smoker kits so you can restock or gift it on its own. Each bottle is crafted with all-natural ingredients and no artificial additives, giving 32 servings at roughly a quarter-ounce per drink.
What makes the Old Fashioned Mixes stand out
Signature, Cherry Pecan Pie & Maple After Dark
Choose from the Signature (classic) recipe, Cherry Pecan Pie, Maple After Dark, or a 3-pack bundling Classic, Maple Brown Sugar and Cherry Pecan for variety.
All-natural, no artificial anything
The syrup is built from dark sweet cherry juice concentrate, natural orange extract, natural gentian root extract, natural cinnamon extract, natural clove extract, natural cardamom extract, citric acid, real sugar and purified water — with no preservatives, artificial flavors, colors or sweeteners.
32 drinks per bottle
Each bottle is portioned to yield 32 smooth, satisfying drinks at about a quarter-ounce serving per cocktail, keeping the per-drink cost reasonable for a premium, small-batch mixer.
Award-recognized recipe
Aged & Charred's broader Old Fashioned recipe line carries "Signature Sip Award" branding on some of its packaging and imagery, and the brand has been referenced by outlets like Food & Wine and Bourbon Inspector.
Full spec sheet
| Type | All-natural Old Fashioned cocktail syrup |
| Flavors | Signature, Cherry Pecan Pie, Maple After Dark, 3-pack |
| Yield | 32 drinks per bottle (~1/4 oz per serving) |
| Key ingredients | Dark sweet cherry juice concentrate, natural orange/gentian root/cinnamon/clove/cardamom extracts, citric acid, real sugar, purified water |
| Additives | None — no preservatives, artificial flavors, colors or sweeteners |
| Made in | USA |
| Price | From $23.99 |
| Shipping | Free on orders over $50 |
| Returns | Free 30-day returns (60-day during holidays) |
Pros & Cons
Pros
- All-natural ingredients — no preservatives or artificial additives.
- Made in the USA with carefully sourced ingredients.
- 32 drinks per bottle keeps cost-per-cocktail reasonable.
- Multiple flavor variants, including a 3-pack for variety.
- Pairs naturally with Aged & Charred's smoker kits.
- Lowest price point in the Aged & Charred lineup (from $23.99).
Cons
- No public star rating or review count shown on the product page.
- Individual flavor variants can go in and out of stock — check availability before ordering.
- A consumable, not a reusable tool — you'll need to reorder over time.
- Exact bottle volume (oz) is not stated on the product page beyond the 32-serving yield.
Answers before you buy
What flavors are available?
How many drinks does one bottle make?
Is it really all-natural?
Do I need a smoker kit to use this syrup?
Where is it made?
What's the shipping and return policy?
A clean-label upgrade for your Old Fashioned
The Old Fashioned Mixes deliver genuine all-natural ingredients at an accessible price point. This score is the Teelacodes Editorial Team's own assessment based on the product's published ingredients and features — not a customer rating, since none was publicly available at the time of writing.
This page contains affiliate links. Teelacodes may earn a commission when you click through and complete a qualifying purchase, at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure policy. Prices, stock and promotion terms can change without notice — always confirm the final total and availability on agedandcharred.com before ordering.
